Well, I don’t usually watch American Idol. I did way back in the day, the whole first season, with Justin and Kelly, and then the second season with Reuben and Clay, but after that I kind of lost interest. (I also lost my cable TV at the time, which may have had something to do with it.) But this year I have TV, and for some reason, a couple of weeks ago, I decided to tune in and see what’s going on.
Oh! I remember what it was that got me interested again. It was Susan Boyle. Who hasn’t seen and heard Susan Boyle? Fantastic! What a story! And what do you think, should she have a makeover or not? Well, she’s had sort of a mini-makeover, last I heard, but that’s as far as she should go, I think.
But I digress. What happened was, I was reading something about Susan Boyle, and Britain’s Got Talent, and they were comparing it to American Idol, and saying how AI has lost it’s spark, so I guess that was what made me want to tune in and see what was happening over on this side of the pond.
Well, I beg to differ. No spark lost here. By the time I tuned in, they were down to four very accomplished performers. I got to see the red-headed girl be voted off, which was really sad, because I liked her, she was quite different than your usual run-of-the-mill Idol hopeful, and I thought she did a great job singing with Adam.
But now there’s three. Three really cute guys, who can all sing like mad. Except now there’s only two, because last night, Danny Gokey got voted off.
And once again, I’m sad. Because I really liked Danny. I thought he was definitely the cutest of the bunch (love the glasses! And the smile…), and his voice has the most personality. But the American Public (or some boardroom full of Idol executives posing as the American Public, I’m still not completely sure the show isn’t rigged) said “No. Goodbye, Gokey.”
And he’s gone.
Only he’s not. Is he? Because I fully suspect he’ll have a singing career. In fact, I would be very surprised if all four of the young singers I have seen this year don’t end up having some kind of singing career. I think they’re all good, and marketable.
But here’s the strange thought I had today.
So last night, Danny was voted off. And next week it will be either Kris or Adam who DOESN’T get to be the American Idol. But you know what…
So what?
Is it really that great to be the American Idol? As I mentioned, I was watching during season two, when Rueben Studdard “won” over Clay Aiken. But today, who’s got the more successful career? And it may have happened before, during some of the other seasons when I wasn’t watching (I’m not really sure, but I wouldn’t be surprised).
Here’s the thing: when you win as the American Idol, your career is immediately placed in the hands of…who? Some record executives that YOU DIDN’T CHOOSE. They’re going to mold you and fashion you and your career into some vision that THEY have, and it may not be what you would choose for yourself.
But the “losers” in second and third place, they may have different record companies come courting THEM. And they may get to pick and choose to a greater degree than the Idol “winner” gets to do. They may get to call at least SOME of the shots.
So when Danny got “voted off” maybe he wasn’t saying “Oh, crap, I didn’t get it!” Maybe he was saying “Whew! That was close. I almost got locked in.” Maybe he’s relieved that he will now have the opportunity to have a greater degree of control over how his career will proceed.
Or….maybe not. Maybe I have no idea what I’m talking about. Maybe I need to stop worrying about American Idol and get a life. đ But I do hope that in that life, at some point in the future, I’ll be able to buy a Danny Gokey CD.